September of:

 1964 - Pam Schroeder
 1965 - Ellen Kallner
 1966 - Eva Rase
 1967 - Margaret Strickland
 1968 - LaVonda Nickell
 1969 - Mary Ellen Creekbaum 
 1970 - Diane Childers
 1971 - Cindy Hickman
 1972 - Paula Bender
 1973 - Merryn Phipps
 1974 - Fran Conkle
 1975 - Tina Carpenter
 1976 - LuAnn Conkle
1977 - Jeannie Holbrook
 1978 - Robin Snyder
 1979 - Pam Jackson
 1980 - Kim Caudill
 1981 - Tracy Boyer
 1982 - Kelli Brafford
 1983 - Dawn Whitaker
 1984 - Jennifer Purcell
 1985 - Amy Truglio
1986 - Tuesday Salyers
 1987 - Lori Gampp
 1988 - Tammy Storey
 1989 - Jodi McGraw
 1990 - Lynn Gampp
 1991 - Heather McGraw
 1992 - Angie Flaig
 1993 - Amy Evans
 1994 - Erica Caudill
1995 - Julia Hale
1996 - Amy Smith
 1997 - Courtney Mallory
 1998 - Angie Swords
 1999 - Courtney McManus
 2000 - Noel Hoskins
 2001 - Jessica Risner
 2002 - Kara Blackburn
 2003 - Arrika Shonkwiler
 2004 - Alicia Dayton
 2005 - Terah Reynolds

 2006 - Allie Farragher

 2007 - Jenny Williams

 2008 - Morgan Gullion

 2009 - Eden Clark

 2010 - Chelsey Vaughn

 2011 - Paige Wiseman

 2012 - Elizabeth Brisker

 2013 - Alexis Commeans

 2014 - Rian Montavon

 2015 - Brookelyn McBee

 2016 - Tori Reffit

 2017 - Zoe Doll

 2018 - Molly Downey

 2019 - Sydney Speas

 2020 - Ezra Veach
 2021 - Bella Reffit
 2022 - Mychal Cron
2023 - Emily Cram